Section

History

The improbable seasons and the long, messy argument over how college sports picks a champion — told with the receipts.

The long argument over how college sports picks a champion, told with the receipts. Three pieces, each built on the record rather than on memory: the statistically improbable seasons that people still misremember, the data history of the walk from the BCS to a twelve-team playoff, and how the NCAA tournament bracket grew into the thing everyone fills out in March. The point of a history section on a numbers site is calibration — nearly every complaint about the current format was made about the one before it, and the record shows which of those complaints turned out to be right. Read these before assuming a present-day debate is new.